The unofficial but so much more realistic National Teams ranking
Forum index >> TeamHB discussions >> The unofficial but so much more realistic National Teams ranking Goto page : 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10
 
Posted on 2021-05-23 11:53:06   
Stoik
Posts: 1301
Joined: 2009-09-25
Offline
Following the topic right there :
https://www.teamhb.org/index.php?page=community&subpage=viewt&t=8253
to incite every national teams to reduce and finally to eliminate of the game the 40+ years old player NT who are rotting the game and will soon make it looks like an unbelievable joke, I propose this new ranking to motivate every NT coach to go that way... And of course because it's cool and more exciting to have something more dynamic and realistic !

So here is the formula :

First, the points of the World Cup won't be distribituted very differently than now :

Winner : 1000 pts
Finalist : 600 pts
Semi-finalists : 350 pts (+ 50 points for the 3rd)
Quarter-finalists : 150 pts
--------------------------------------------------
each WC pool victory : 40 pts
each WC pool draw : 20 pts
--------------------------------------------------
Bonus for WC qualification : 100 pts
each WC qualifications victory : 20 pts
each WC qualifications draw : 10 pts

BUT

For each 40+ years old player in the team, the points will decrease of 20% (and 40% for a 50+ yo ), so that means a team with more than four 40 yo players will have no points even if it wins the World Cup

And

For a more realistic and dynamic ranking (not as a "cumulative points" one, as in the game) : after each world cup, the points earned by the teams during the previous ones will decrease every season of 20%.
example : a team which won 800 Pts the first year, 100 the second year and 40 the 3rd year, would have at the end of the 3rd year :
800x80%x80% + 150x80% + 40 = 512+120+40= 672 pts
NB : So, after 10 seasons, a win of 1000 points will become a little more than 100 points, what sounds good to me cause it still has some impact on the ranking but not too much




Palmares :

Season 1 (33) : 1. Slovakia 2. Poland - 3. Czechia
Season 2 (34) : 1. Spain 2. Romania - 3. Czechia
Season 3 (35) : 1. Czechia 2. Spain - 3. Poland
Season 4 (36) : 1. Denmark 2. Croatia - 3. Czechia
Season 5 (37) : 1. Romania 2. Slovakia - 3. Croatia
Season 6 (38) : 1. Serbia 2. Mexico - 3. Czechia
Season 7 (39) : 1. Serbia 2. Denmark - 3. Slovakia



Last edited on 2024-01-26 at 11:48

Bronzés, barjots, costauds, experts, tels sont les Melons !

Posted on 2021-05-23 12:00:43   
Stoik
Posts: 1301
Joined: 2009-09-25
Offline
GENERAL RANKING :
(after season 39)

1. Serbia..........2279 (1260+1274x80%) (+4)

2. Denmark......1863 (690+1466x80%) (+1)
3. Czechia........1669 (250+1774x80%) (-1)

4. Romania.......1596 (176+1775x80%) (-3)
5. Slovakia........1465 (372+1366x80%) (-1)
6. Poland..........1191 (210+1226x80%) (0)
7. Croatia.........1077 (160+1146x80%) (0)
8. Spain............1020 (240+975x80%) (+1)
9. France............983 (210+966x80%) (+1)
10. Italy..............900 (32+1085x80%) (-2)

11. Hungary.......674 (336+423x80%) (+4)
12. Belgium........568 (172+495x80%) (+1)
13. Russia..........565 (276+361x80%) (+4)
14. Mexico..........514 (24+613x80%) (-3)
15. Sweden........511 (48+579x80%) (-3)
16. United K.......445 (60+481x80%) (-2)
17. Portugal.......390 (60+412x80%) (-1)
18. Australia.......389 (160+286x80%) (0)
19. Macedonia....364 (246+148x80%) (+1)
20. Iceland.........346 (180+208x80%) (-1)

21. Brazil............172 (60+140x80%) (0)
22. Switzerld......112 (36+95x80%) (+3)
23. U.S.A.............109 (0+136x80%) (-1)
24. Slovenia........102 (0+127x80%) (-1)
25. Ukraine...........91 (0+114x80%) (-1)
26. Germany.........68 (0+85x80%) (0)
27. China..............62 (40+28x80%) (+1)
28. Argentina........30 (0+38x80%) (-1)
29. Netherlds........11 (0+14x80%) (0)
30. Austria..............6 (0+8x80%) (0)

31. Bosnia Herzegovina
32. Latvia
Last edited on 2024-01-26 at 11:43

Bronzés, barjots, costauds, experts, tels sont les Melons !

Posted on 2021-05-23 12:51:22   
Stoik
Posts: 1301
Joined: 2009-09-25
Offline
World Cup season 39 :

1. Serbia (0)..1260 (0+2x20+0+2x20+100+0+2x40+150+200+250+400)
2. Denmark (0)...690 (3x20+0+0+10+1003x40+150+200+50)
3. Slovakia (2)....372 (12+6+0+12+12+12+60+24+24+0+90+120)
4. Hungary (3)....336 (8+8+0+4+0+4+40+16+0+16+60+80+100)
5. Russia (2).......276 (0+12+12+12+12+6+60+24+24+24+90)
6. Czechia (0).....250 (20+10+20+20+20+20+100+0+0+40)
7. Macedo. (2)....246 (0+0+12+12+12+12+60+24+24+0+90)
8. Spain (0)........240 (20+20+20+20+0+0+100+0+20+40)
9. Poland (0)......210 (10+20+20+20+20+0+100+20+0+0)
9. France (0).......210 (0+10+20+20+0+20+100+0+40+0)
11. Iceland (0)....180 (0+20+20+20+20+0+100+0+0+0)
12. Romania (1)..176 (16+0+16+16+16+16+80+16+0+0)
13. Belgium (3)....172 (8+8+8+8+0+8+40+16+16+0+60)
14. Australia (0)...160 (20+20+0+0+10+10+100+0+0+0)
14. Croatia (1).....160 (16+0+16+0+0+16+80+0+0+32)
16. Portugal (0).....60 (20+20+0+0+20+0)
16. Brazil (0)..........60 (20+20+0+20+0+0)
16. United K. (0)....60 (0+20+0+0+20+20)
19. Sweden (1).....48 (16+16+0+0+16+0)
20. China (0).........40 (10+10+20+0+0+0)
21. Switzerld (2)....36 (12+0+12+0+12+0)
22. Italy (1)...........32 (16+0+0+16+0+0)
23. Mexico (1)........24 (0+0+0+8+0+16)
24. Slovenia (0).......0 (0+0+0+0+0+0)
24. Austria (1).........0 (0+0+0+0+0+0)
24. Netherlds (4).....0 (0+0+0+0+0+0)

27. U.S.A. (DQ-6)
28. Ukraine (DQ-7)
29. Argentina (DQ-4+2)
30. Germany (DQ-7+1)
31. Bosnia Herzegovina (DQ-2+5)
32. Latvia (DQ-6+7)

(DQ-X+Y) : DQ = disqualified ; X = number of 40+ yo players ; Y = number of 50+ yo players
Last edited on 2024-01-25 at 23:59

Bronzés, barjots, costauds, experts, tels sont les Melons !

Posted on 2021-05-24 15:39:51   
Hadar
Posts: 2317
Joined: 2012-02-02
Offline
Stoik wrote:


So here is the formula :
First, the points of the World Cup won't be distribituted very differently than now :
Winner : 1000 pts
Finalist : 600 pts
Semi-finalists : 400 pts (+ the points of a normal victory for the 3rd)
Quarter-finalists : 250 pts
Bonus for WC qualification : 50 pts
Every victory : 20 pts
Every draw : 10 pts
For each 40+ years old player in the team, the points will decrease of 20%, so that means a team with more than 4 of 40 yo players will have no points even if it wins the World Cup
for a more realistic and updated ranking : after each world cup, the points earned by the teams during the previous ones will decrease every season, let's say about 20% for the moment.



Good idea

Posted on 2021-05-24 15:53:08   
MIREK 70
Posts: 2806
Joined: 2011-01-02
Offline
Hadar wrote:

Stoik wrote:


So here is the formula :
First, the points of the World Cup won't be distribituted very differently than now :
Winner : 1000 pts
Finalist : 600 pts
Semi-finalists : 400 pts (+ the points of a normal victory for the 3rd)
Quarter-finalists : 250 pts
Bonus for WC qualification : 50 pts
Every victory : 20 pts
Every draw : 10 pts
For each 40+ years old player in the team, the points will decrease of 20%, so that means a team with more than 4 of 40 yo players will have no points even if it wins the World Cup
for a more realistic and updated ranking : after each world cup, the points earned by the teams during the previous ones will decrease every season, let's say about 20% for the moment.



Good idea




Posted on 2021-05-25 0:05:38   
Ragnbone
Posts: 41
Joined: 2019-11-11
ONLINE!
I agree wholeheartly with the proposal of manager Stoik.

I think It goes even farther than my original idea in the other post.


Posted on 2021-05-25 9:36:26   
Stoik
Posts: 1301
Joined: 2009-09-25
Offline
Thanks guys ! I hope you will "enjoy" !

Bronzés, barjots, costauds, experts, tels sont les Melons !

Posted on 2021-07-04 14:17:13   
Stoik
Posts: 1301
Joined: 2009-09-25
Offline
Ranking after the World Cup's quarterfinals updated above !

(I adjusted the points distribution to make them more progressive at the levels of quarterfinals and semifinals)


Bronzés, barjots, costauds, experts, tels sont les Melons !

Posted on 2021-07-08 13:20:52   
Stoik
Posts: 1301
Joined: 2009-09-25
Offline
Test ranking of this season is done !

Congrats to Poland to have become the winner of this test due to their great World Cup results combined with the "credibility", the "vraisemblance" of their squad with no players above 39 years old !


...and of course congrats to Czech Republic for their final victory ! (with "only" 4 too much old players)

So what do you think managers about this ranking ? Any comment or/and suggestion ?

Bronzés, barjots, costauds, experts, tels sont les Melons !

Posted on 2021-07-09 0:11:29   
Sir Antonio
Posts: 53
Joined: 2021-01-25
Offline
Thank you so much for congrats Personally I feel unsatisfied. I have gained a lot of experience and knowledge through this tournament. If I can get the re-election we will aim higher.

Congratulations for Czech Republic, Bosnia and Spain!

It was an interesting tournament
Forum index >> TeamHB discussions >> The unofficial but so much more realistic National Teams ranking Goto page : 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10